The Apostles’ Youth Reveals a Greater Sacrifice

by Elizabeth Turello –

Photo of the apostles from The Chosen. Used with permission from The Chosen press.
This image is used with permission from The Chosen.

Growing up, I was used to seeing the Twelve Apostles depicted as middle age or older: Da Vinci’s Last Supper, Ghirlandaio’s Vocation of the Apostles and Caravaggio’s The Incredulity of St. Thomas, to name a few. Mel Gibson’s The Passion of the Christ in 2004 broke away from this with a fairly young actor, Christo Jivkov (around age 29), who played the disciple John. Still, the others were largely in their 40s and 50s — mature, grown adults. It wasn’t until Dallas Jenkins’ The Chosen that I realized the apostles were younger than I ever imagined.

The Chosen’s Portrayal of the Apostles

Like millions of Christians around the world, I’ve become enamored with The Chosen. As the show runners remind us, it’s not a substitute for Scripture by any means, but an aid. There’s something powerful about seeing these crucial biblical moments brought to life in a realistic, relatable manner. One of my favorite scenes from the show is the portrayal of Luke Chapter 5, “The Call of Simon the Fisherman.” In it, Simon’s initial resistance to accept Jesus as the Messiah is emphasized by actor Shahar Isaac. He demonstrates the stubbornness and griping of an immature young adult who thinks he knows better, not the response of a humble, obedient full adult with life experience.

But when his boat begins to overflow with fish, Simon’s disbelief turns into belief, and he throws himself at the feet of Christ, confessing his unworthiness. It was here, at the feet of Christ with tears streaming down his face and a broken voice — a child begging their father for forgiveness — that I noticed just how young Simon truly was.

From then on, I started focusing on the other apostles in the show. Andrew, Simon Peter’s brother, appears slightly more youthful. Sons of Thunder, James and John, mirror Peter and Andrew’s age group. Little by little, each apostle is introduced and all seem to be between their mid-20s and early 30s.

This casting choice didn’t match the paintings, icons and other performances I’d come to know over the years. I’ll admit, seeing the apostles portrayed as older always left me confused. In addition to imagining the apostles two to three decades older than Jesus, their Teacher (which didn’t make sense to me), I was curious when it came to the rest of their lives. Because if Peter was 50 when he was called to follow Christ, that would have made him around 80 when he was martyred; maybe 60 if we go with one of the more youthful approaches, or upwards of 90 if we consider other depictions I’ve seen. If John was only a few years younger, then he would have been nearly 100 when he wrote his Gospel. These ages aren’t outrageous per say, but imagining them like this took away some of my admiration of the true power of their sacrifices.

An Accurate Depiction

I was left wondering just how old the apostles were then when they were called to follow Christ. Extensive research revealed that, based off historical and cultural evidence, John, the youngest, was anywhere from 15 to 18 and Peter, the oldest, 26 to 30. This means that, on average, most of the apostles were somewhere in their 20s during the time of Christ’s ministry, a far cry from the typical depiction we are accustomed to.

But why do their ages matter? It doesn’t change the stories in the Gospel or the fact that all made immense sacrifices for our Lord and His Church.

For the first time, though, I was able to place myself in the apostles’ shoes. As a 24-year-old, the extent of their situations finally hit me. These weren’t men who had already lived full lives; they were boys who had full lives ahead of them. Before Christ called them, they were starting successful careers, looking forward to the prospect of marriage (Peter is the only one we know for certain was married; see Lk 4:38), raising children and much more. When Christ called me, it wasn’t easy to give up certain things or face the harsh judgement and sometimes hatred of the secular world, although I know full well it’s worth it. I imagine the apostles felt similarly; honored to be called by Christ, but aware — maybe even uncertain — of the sacrifices it entailed.

By acknowledging the youth of the apostles, we gain a new perspective on their willingness to follow, and eventually die for, Christ. These weren’t men having mid-life crises who abandoned their families and work in search of an adventure because they were bored. They didn’t embrace martyrdom because they were going to die soon anyway, so “might as well make it count.” The disciples were young adolescents and early adults who, not knowing what was to come, didn’t hesitate to offer up the normal lives promised to them by Jewish society the moment Jesus said, “Come, follow me.” (Mt 19:21)

Elizabeth Turello

This article will appear in the upcoming 2023 Second Issue of Soul Magazine. Elizabeth Turello is the Communications Associate for the World Apostolate of Fatima USA/Blue Army Shrine.

Like this content? Help us spread the message of Fatima.

4 Responses

  1. Thank you for writing this! It does make their calling and following if Jesus even more inspiring, if that’s possible!

  2. Some are blind to see the blasphemy that are in The Chosen. We are suppose to be Our Lady’s Blue Army defending her honor. OUR BEAUTIFUL MOTHER MARY IS JESUS MOTHER! You should of did the research before using The Chosen as an example. This is why we need to go to the Bible it will tell you the truth. In Season 2, Episode 3 has major blasphemy against the Mother of God. When you praise and honor Our Beautiful Virgin Mother Mary we are honoring and praising her son Jesus. Do you think Our Heavenly Father is pleased when the Beautiful Virgin Mary who is Full of Grace is blasphemied? I realize that you are writing about the Apostles and not Mary. But is that like going into an abortion clinic to have an ultrasound done. You are not having an abortion so….what’s the harm? Was there better places to go then the abortion clinic to have an ultrasound done? I think so! Could you not have gone to a better resource to write your article. If they have blasphemy against Our Beautiful Mother why lead others on a uncertain path. Dont leave it up to hollywood to inspire you but Our All Powerful God thru His Son Jesus Christ with the Holy Spirit One God forever and ever. Be careful where you lead the sheep. Lead them to the Good Shepherd not the shepherd wearing wolf clothing. So many just follow because everyone thinks its good and look away when bad comes along but dont we do that for good comedy shows or drama shows. We have a customed ourself to this but we have to start seeing and stop being blind to all this it is numbing us. And this is not good!!!

    1. Debbie,

      Thank you for your comment. Yes, there are scenes I wish had been shown/filmed differently. But extracting the positive from the show and obvious draw to Christ it has created can be acknowledged. We are all sinners and fighting blasphemy can be done in many ways.

      There are many Catholics watching the series and enjoying it. And there are many priests and theologians who offer us a good response. One in particular that I highly recommend is on with Dr. Michael Barber and Dr. Scott Hefelfinger in which they address all the issues with the Catholic faith on this series. It is very well done and welcome for all who are drawn to this wonderful presentation of Jesus’ life with Jonathan Roumie, as Jesus, who is a very devout Catholic. The Chosen does have a Catholic priest and a rabbi on their team. As it is directed by a Protestant group who, as we know, have a sticking point with Mary, it is certain that the priest and rabbi are not able to insert too much heady theology into it without turning it into something that is not perceived or understood in the moment. While they don’t understand the full scope of Mary’s role and the theology of this, we can take what’s good about this series, be drawn closer to the person and mission of Jesus, and follow the commentaries, broken down by season and episode on Formed. You can access that commentary on

      I would also draw your attention to an article written about this from a Catholic priest on Catholic Answers:

      God Bless & Mary keep you in her Immaculate Heart,

  3. What an insightful article! The Chosen has helped give millions a more “3 dimensional “ picture of this time! What a blessing. After about 50 years as a Christian, I am digging and learning more!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Stay Up to Date!

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.